[Verse 1]
I wish I could paint your world so beautiful
And I wish I could make it right
But of all the things I could ever want for you
I wish this more than life
[Chorus]
Love the Lord with all your heart
With all your soul, your mind and strength
Love the Lord with all your heart
With all your soul, your mind and strength
[Verse 2]
If I could give you back your innocence
And if I could turn back time
If I could heal you of all the broken promises
Still the greatest thing in life
[Chorus]
Is love the Lord with all your heart
With all your soul, your mind and strength
Love the Lord with all your heart
With all your soul, your mind and strength
[Outro]
Love the Lord with all your heart
With all your soul, your mind and strength
Love the Lord with all your heart
With all your soul, your mind and strength
Your heart and soul, your mind and strength
Your heart and soul, your mind and strength
I Wish
Song Meaning
Nicole C. Mullen names limits before making any request in "I Wish" — "I wish I could paint your world so beautiful, and I wish I could make it right, but of all the things I could ever want for you, I wish this more than life" — admitting she can't grant what she wishes for before naming the one wish that matters most.
The chorus doesn't explain that wish; it quotes it directly, borrowing the Great Commandment word for word — "love the Lord with all your heart, with all your soul, your mind and strength" — letting scripture's own words carry the entire hope rather than paraphrasing it.
"If I could give you back your innocence, and if I could turn back time, if I could heal you of all the broken promises" lists specific damage the singer admits she's powerless to undo, and "still the greatest thing in life" pivots away from repair toward the one thing that was never actually lost. The repeated chorus, doubling by the end into "your heart and soul, your mind and strength" stated twice, lets the borrowed command outlast every wish the song couldn't fulfill on its own.